The Grim Reaper Patch Circulating Among Guards at ‘Alligator Alcatraz’
Who is the guard behind the patch? How a patch from his uniform surfaced outside the remote Everglades ICE detention center.
This rolling investigation is ongoing and will be updated. Two Can Be True is the weekly newsletter of longtime investigative journalist, Monique O. Madan.
Please submit all tips to monique.twocanbetrue@gmail.com or direct message me.
Outside a remote immigration detention facility in the Florida Everglades known as “Alligator Alcatraz,” an activist was handed something unusual by a departing guard: a patch from his uniform.
The patch shows a large alligator skull with its jaws open wide above a hooded skeleton holding a hatchet. The skeleton, depicted with red eyes and resembling a grim reaper, stands before silhouettes of guard towers and fencing that resemble a prison compound. Red banners frame the image with the words “Alligator Alcatraz” on one side and “You Can’t Hide” on the other.
The guard, who identified himself as “Officer Martinez” and was wearing a Special Housing Unit uniform, told an activist that he had the patches made and distributed them to other guards working inside the detention center.
“He told me he made the patches and that he gives them to people — including other guards,” said Courtney Prokopas, 41, an activist with Witness at the Border, a volunteer advocacy group that organizes demonstrations outside immigration detention centers across the country. She had traveled from St. Petersburg and camped out for several days outside the facility.
To verify whether guards inside the facility wore the patch, a detainee recently released from the center was asked over the phone whether anything about the guards’ uniforms stood out to him.
Without being shown the patch, he described the insignia.
“What I saw was ‘Alligator Alcatraz,’ a skeleton dressed in black holding a hatchet and a crocodile underneath,” said Lewis Ortigoza, who had been detained at the facility. “It looked like something demonic.”
On March 7, during a FaceTime call, Ortigoza was shown the patch obtained from the guard and confirmed it matched the one he had seen worn by officers inside the facility.
“Yes,” he said. “That one.”
When reached by phone and asked for Martinez, the man who answered confirmed his identity. After being told the call was about the altercation and the patches, he hung up.
Mike King, an emergency management consultant and emergency manager at the Florida detention site affiliated with Critical Response Strategies, identified the guard as “Steven Martinez.”
“I can confirm that he and another officer were both demobilized for following an altercation between the two,” King said, noting that he not seen the patch before and that it is not an authorized part of the uniform.
GUARD DISCHARGED
Prokopas said she was standing outside the facility on March 3 holding a cardboard sign that read “SHAME” when Martinez stopped his truck near the entrance gate while waiting for a break in traffic to pull onto U.S. 41. The two began speaking through the open window of his vehicle.
During the exchange, Martinez told her he had just been fired after fighting with another officer. He had fresh gashes on his face.
Prokopas said Martinez was wearing the patch on his uniform. She said he then removed it from his shoulder and handed it to her.
Visibly upset, Martinez told Prokopas that he previously worked for the Bexar County Sheriff’s Office in Texas. He said he had just been discharged from Critical Response Strategies, the private contractor that provides security at the detention center, after a physical altercation with another guard inside the facility.
Martinez told Prokopas he planned to report the incident to the Miccosukee Police Department because the detention center sits on tribal land.
Later that day, he returned to the facility after Miccosukee police told him the matter was outside their jurisdiction.
“He told me to keep the patch. I told him ‘no, it’s okay,’” Prokopas said. “He insisted and said he had plenty.”
When Martinez returned, she said, he was wearing another of the same patch on his shoulder.
On March 7, an officer with the Miccosukee Police Department confirmed that a man had walked into the department on Tuesday, March 3, seeking to report a physical altercation with another guard at the detention center because it is located on tribal land. The officer said he was turned away because the facility falls under the state’s jurisdiction, not the tribe’s.
The facility sits on land associated with the Miccosukee Tribe but is operated by federal immigration authorities, creating overlapping jurisdiction between tribal, state and federal agencies.
Florida Highway Patrol, which investigates incidents on the premises, said it is “looking into this.” So is The Florida Department of Law Enforcement and the Bexar County Sheriff’s Office.
REMOTE FACILITY
The detention center — located deep in the Florida Everglades — houses migrants detained by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement while they await immigration proceedings. The site is widely known as “Alligator Alcatraz,” a name introduced by Florida officials when it was announced and later embraced by President Donald Trump.
The facility sits in a remote stretch of the Everglades surrounded by wetlands and wildlife — including many alligators — miles from major population centers.
On any given day, tens of thousands of migrants are held in immigration detention facilities across the United States while they await immigration proceedings and deportation.
In the past year alone, at least 40 people have died while in immigration detention, according to data compiled from federal records and watchdog groups that track deaths in custody. The deaths have intensified scrutiny over detention conditions and the oversight of facilities operated by private contractors.
Immigration enforcement actions have also drawn heightened attention following several high-profile incidents involving U.S. citizens. At least three U.S. citizens have died in encounters tied to immigration enforcement operations in the past year.
Many immigration detention facilities are staffed in part by private contractors responsible for security, transportation and other operations. Critics have long raised concerns that the use of private contractors can complicate oversight and accountability when incidents occur inside detention facilities.
The Everglades detention center relies on security personnel from Critical Response Strategies, the contractor Martinez said he worked for when he distributed the patches. Prokopas said the guard who approached her was wearing a uniform bearing the company’s logo.
U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement and the Department of Homeland Security did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
THE SYMBOL
Ortigoza said the patch always made his heart race.
He said the patches were worn by guards throughout the facility, not just in solitary confinement areas.
“It felt like they were meant to make us even more afraid than we already were,” he said. “I always felt haunted by it but I never said anything because I was so afraid.”
“I was paying attention to everything, and I noticed it,” he said, noting that guards sometimes removed and reattached the patches. “They had it attached to their shoulder. They had more than one type, but the one that impacted me the most was that one… It made me feel like I was bound to die.”
Ortigoza said he spent 21 days inside the detention center before being released in late February on bond — an outcome that is relatively rare in immigration detention cases.
Custom “morale patches” have become increasingly common among some military and law enforcement units, often featuring aggressive imagery or slogans intended to build camaraderie among personnel. In recent years, however, several departments have moved to prohibit unofficial patches after public criticism that some designs glorify violence or intimidation.
For Ortigoza, the former detainee who recognized the symbol, the patch was difficult to ignore.
“When you’re in there,” he said, “you notice everything.”
This rolling investigation will be updated as more information becomes available.
To submit a tip, email monique.twocanbetrue@gmail.com or direct message me.
Ways to Support My Work
Independent reporting like this is reader-supported. If you’d like to help sustain it, here are a few ways:
1. Become a paid subscriber
Subscribe monthly or annually to support original reporting and essays on Two Can Be True.
2. Make a one-time contribution
If subscriptions aren’t your thing, you can safely support my reporting directly here.
3. Help the reporting reach more people
• Share this story on social media and/group chats
• Forward this newsletter to a friend
• Reply with tips, ideas, or feedback
Every bit of support helps keep independent journalism alive. Thank you for being part of this community.
Subscribe to Two Can Be True for more content like this.
Follow me on LinkedIn, Instagram, X, Threads and Facebook, and join the community chat to keep the conversation going.
Two Can Be True is published by The Madan Creative Group LLC.
Great reporting, Monique! Keep on em
Terrifying